31 Jul 2010 
Support Center » Knowledgebase » PMP e-SIM Expert Comments
Knowledgebase Categories
The knowledgebase is organized into different categories; please select a category that you are interested in. You can also search the entire knowledgebase by entering keywords in the navigation bar beside this text.


 Articles
 Project Lifecycle vs Product Lifecycle - Mini Exam, Framework, Question 5
  Student's Question: Mini Exam, Framework, Question 5 It is clear that B and D are incorrect. No problem there. That leaves A and C as the remaining options.I don't see how C is the best answer: There is a difference between "product lifecycle" and "project lifecycle" where according to the PMBOK, it is the product lifecycle that is usually industry specific.Also it is a fundamental tenet of PMI that projects should always have Initiation, Planning, Execution, CONTOL, and Closing phases. The question would make much more sense if it reads "A product lifecycle" rather than "A project lifecycle" PMP expert's Answer: It's good you are asking for clarification on these similar wording life cycles as they are completely different. Many students confuse these terms and/or think they are the same at the beginning of their studying. There are 3 fundamental dimensions of lifecycle concepts we need to understand as the exam will definitely test you on these concepts: So let's start with defining each of the 3 lifecycle terms as follows: 1. The project MANAGEMENT life cycle is made up of the 44 unique processes grouped by the 5 process groups - initiate, plan, execute, monitor and control and close out. These 44 processes are not so much sequential in application but, integrative, iterative and simultaneous throughout each of the project lifecycle phases as required, based on the complexity and timeline etc of your project. In other words, for each of the phases of our projects, we will initiate, do planning, monitor and control and of course we close out each phase before we proceed to the next phase in the project. 2. Now the project lifecycle is a grouping of any number of sequential phases which make up
 Operational Definitions - Baseline Post-Test Quality #8
  Student's Question: Baseline Post-Test Quality #8The Question reads: "All of the following are inputs to the quality ASSURANCE process except:" According to PMBOK, section 8.2.1 inputs to quality assurance are Quality management Plan Quality Metrics Process Improvement Plan Work Performance Infomation Approved Change Requests Quality Control Measurements Implemented Change Requests Implemented Corrective Actions Implemented Preventative Actions That leaves "A" and "C" as both being technically correct. Now since the BEST answer is what I need to select, it seems to me that since: Based on Figure 8.2, the Project Quality Management Process Flow Diagram, outputs from the Quality Planning block are inputs into the Perform Quality Assurance block, AND Based on section 8.1.3, Checlists are an output of the Quality Planning block, AND Since "operational definitions" is mentioned nowhere in niether the Quality Planning block nor the Perform Quality Assurance block
 Bribery - Random Simulator: #43 Professional Responsiblity
  Random Simulator: #43 Professional ResponsiblityStudent's Question: "C" would appear to be a better answer. You run into the problem that if you pick the contractor whose wife is in charge of the "local group" that gave the golf balls, then an appearance of bribery is likely. This would not be good for the project. If you give the balls back then no such appearance is possible. In addition one should give the balls back with no strings attached. After the bidding process is finished the "local group" can give the balls if they are so inclined however that should not be part of the deal when giving the balls back.Expert's Answer: I agree with you that we must always be sensitive to the "appearance of bribery". I really feel in this scenario that there was no intent for bribery for the following reasons: It appears this is a small community, the contractors wife is known for her community involvement, this is a project for a non profit organization so expectation is that many groups will donate time, in kind and/gifts, the cost of the golf balls is relatively inexpensive, and lastly and most important the PM is not reaping any direct benefits at all. Hope this helps explain why we would accept this inexpensive donation in this scenario.
 CAPM Mini Exam, Cost, Question 12 - management reserve
  Student's Question:Subject is management reserves. I don't think the answer is correct or is ambiguous at best.  Nowhere in the PMBOK does it say that these reserves require a change to the plan as stated in the supposed correct answer. If these reserves are already approved as part of the plan why would they require a change? D is actually a better answer as they are part of the plan which would have had to have been approved by projust sponsors at some point in time... Expert's Reply: Thanks for bringing the reference typo to our attention Russ. We will update this for our next release. Re the Management Contingency Reserve: When referencing "the Plan" it is safe to assume we are talking about the baseline plan. In order to use management reserves, they must first be approved by the sponsor and once approved, the baseline is adjusted accordingly. We need to adjust the baseline so that we can accurately calculate the earned value of the project. This is also supported on page 173-7.2.3.2. Trust this helps support why we answer B as the correct answer
 Post Test Baseline Time Question 8
  Student's Question:Just a point of clarification, in the post exam baseline exams - Time - Question 8- a project calendar is: A) Another term for a resource calendar B) Identifies when work is allowed. In keeping with the spirit of "best" answer the answer A) seems the best: see PMBOK Glossary for Project Calendar .... See also resource calendar Answer B) when work is allowed seems less correct given the reference to 6.5.3.6 refers to a calendar updates and does not stress 'allowed'. In my experience a project calendar is better used for resource allocation than allowed work (schedule) Can you please elaborate? Expert's Answer: Yes I agree both A and B are similar but I still feel B is the best answer. The Resource calendar is not the same as the project calendar. I agree the PMOBK glossary references the project calendar to the resource calendar and the resource calendar is referenced to the project calendar since they are both required to create the actual schedule. The key difference is the project calendar affects all activities, i.e. due to plant shutdowns, weather, shift work etc, vs the resource is specific to a person, category of persons and availability of material as well. In fact, project calendars are part of the corporate organizational assets. Ref PMBOK page 148 6.5.2.8. I trust this clarifies further why we select B as the best selection in this situation. 
 Float - Pre-test Monitoring and Controlling question #7
  Student's Question:This question is about Pre-test Monitoring and Controlling question #7 and is about float, free float and total float: In the question and the rational for the right answer it says that: 1. Free Float is: =Earliest Start of Following Activity-Earliest Start of Present Activity-Duration of Present Activity. And according the definition the free float this is amount of time an activity can be delayed without delaying the early start of its successor. 2. From other notes the definition for Total float is that it affects the end date of the project. What do you calculate with the following formula LS-ES or LF-EF?. Is the called simply “float” for a specific activity? How do you calculate total float? Do you just sum the float of different activities? Is it possible to use the same formula (LS-ES or LF-EF) to calculate the free float, because when I do it looks like I end up with the same result?Expert's Answer:We need to be careful to understand the differences between free float and total float. Total float is the amount of time that an activity can be delayed without having to reschedule the project completion date. Free float is the amount of time an activity can be delayed without having to reschedule the ES of any other activity in the project. Total Float is shared with all of the other activities in the same path. Therefore using the float in one activity will reduce the float available for the other activities in the path. It is the difference between an activity LF and LS or EF and ES. You do not sum all the float for all activities in the path to get the total float. And then we have Free Float, which is the amount of float that the activity can consume without affecting the earliest start of the successor
 Back
 Search
Do not hesitate to use the search button to find articles and tutorials.

Simply enter your keyword, select the area where you want to search and press search.
 
 
 
 
 
 
If you have submitted a ticket to the support, you may login below to review its status.

Please note the support ticket password was sent to you when you submitted your first ticket.

When you are logged in, click on View Tickets from the Bottom bar.
 Login [Lost Password] 
Email:
Password:
Remember Me:
 
 Main Categories
Home | Submit a Ticket | Knowledgebase | Troubleshooter | Downloads
 

Help Desk Software By Kayako eSupport v3.20.02